Investing9 min read

BIG GERMANY, LITTLE DENMARK

ByBrett S. Chappell

Bureaucracy, Digital Government, and Competitiveness

In 1776, Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations, laying much of the intellectual groundwork for modern economic liberalism. His argument that prosperity flourishes when individuals are free to pursue productive activities, supported by competition, functioning markets, and sound institutions, remains remarkably relevant 250 years later. Smith was no anarchist. He recognized the importance of justice, public infrastructure, and institutions that allow markets to function. His concern was with unnecessary interference, restrictive privileges, and obstacles preventing economic resources from finding their most productive uses.

Two and a half centuries later, bureaucracy remains one such obstacle. A recent study from Florida International University examines its economic cost, with Germany providing a particularly striking example. Denmark, its smaller northern neighbor, was not included in the study, but its international competitiveness and sophisticated digital administration raise an intriguing question: how much of bureaucracy’s economic burden stems from the regulations themselves, and how much from the efficiency with which they are administered?

The Invisible Cost of Bureaucracy

The Adam Smith Center for Economic Freedom at Florida International University recently published its sixth Index of Bureaucracy, examining the administrative burden imposed on small businesses across 27 countries in Europe, Latin America, and the Caribbean. The premise is straightforward: bureaucracy consumes time, and time is an economic resource. Every hour an entrepreneur spends navigating administrative procedures is an hour unavailable for developing products, serving customers, or expanding a business.

The study examines three stages of a company’s existence: opening, running, and closing. Across the participating countries, establishing a small business involves an average of 1,638 hours of administrative procedures and associated delays, recurring compliance consumes another 1,178 hours annually, and closing a business involves an average burden of 3,654 hours. These figures encompass procedural requirements and processing times, not exclusively hours of active administrative labor. They nevertheless illustrate the considerable friction that bureaucracy can introduce into economic activity.

The authors estimate that businesses across the participating countries incur approximately $33 billion annually in administrative costs, excluding fees and other direct charges. From a classical liberal perspective, the implications are clear: regulation may serve legitimate objectives, but its administrative costs are rarely negligible.

Big Germany, Little Denmark

Germany is Europe’s largest economy and one of the world’s great industrial powers. Its engineering capabilities, manufacturing traditions, and Mittelstand have long provided the backbone of European industrial competitiveness. Yet Germany finishes last among the 27 countries examined in the FIU study when it comes to opening a small business. The researchers calculate a weighted average of 3,942 hours for business establishment, compared with just 223 hours in France. Germany’s annual administrative burden for operating a small business reaches 2,457 hours.

Table 1. Administrative hours required to open a small business, selected countries, 2026

Country / benchmarkAdministrative hours
Germany3,942
United Kingdom1,873
27-country average1,638
France223
DenmarkNot included in study

Note. FIU figures are sector-weighted estimates of administrative burden across the opening process. They encompass procedural and processing time and should not be interpreted solely as hours of active employee labor. Denmark was not part of the 27-country sample.

Source. Adam Smith Center for Economic Freedom, Florida International University, Index of Bureaucracy 2026, Figure 1, p. 15.

https://freedom.fiu.edu/index-of-bureaucracy

In Germany, lengthy permitting procedures account for much of the burden, particularly environmental approvals under the Federal Immission Control Act (BImSchG §4), which the FIU identifies as a major bottleneck for the agricultural and manufacturing activities examined (FIU, p. 41). The 3,942 hours therefore reflect substantial processing delays, not simply time spent completing paperwork, an important distinction when comparing countries with different industrial structures.

Nevertheless, Germany’s broader bureaucratic challenges are independently documented. In its July 2026 Monthly Report, the Deutsche Bundesbank reported that surveyed German companies estimated their bureaucracy costs at approximately 7% of annual turnover in 2024, up from 5% in 2022. The Bundesbank also identified weaknesses in digitalization alongside growing regulatory requirements. Germany is hardly lacking in entrepreneurial ability, capital, or technical expertise. The question is whether its administrative architecture allows these resources to operate as efficiently as possible.

Denmark shares a 68-kilometer land border with Germany through the historic region of Schleswig. Geographically close, the two economies nevertheless present rather different profiles in international competitiveness rankings.

Bureaucracy and Competitiveness: Apples and Pears?

According to the IMD World Competitiveness Ranking 2026, Denmark ranks sixth globally among 70 economies, making it the highest-ranked EU member state. Germany places 23rd overall but ranks ahead of Denmark in economic performance, finishing 16th against Denmark’s 25th. The contrast is revealing: Denmark performs substantially better in business and government efficiency, yet Germany leads in economic performance.

Table 2. IMD World Competitiveness Ranking 2026: Denmark versus Germany

Competitiveness measureDenmarkGermany
Overall competitiveness623
Economic performance2516
Government efficiency837
Business efficiency239
Infrastructure211

Note. Rankings among 70 economies; 1 = highest. Bold marks the better-ranked country in each row.

Source. IMD World Competitiveness Yearbook 2026.

https://www.imd.org/centers/wcc/world-competitiveness-center/rankings/world-competitiveness-ranking

At first glance, Denmark’s stronger overall ranking might suggest that it has substantially less bureaucracy than Germany. Such a conclusion would be premature because the FIU index and IMD’s competitiveness ranking measure fundamentally different things. The former examines administrative burdens experienced by small businesses, while the latter evaluates a broader combination of economic performance, government efficiency, business efficiency, and infrastructure. Comparing the two without recognizing their methodological differences is rather like comparing apples and pears.

The Danish economic model combines high taxation, extensive public services, and substantial regulatory obligations with private enterprise, international openness, and strong institutions. Its competitiveness cannot simply be attributed to limited government intervention. The more interesting question is whether the economic burden of regulation depends as much on how efficiently it is administered as on the extent of regulation itself.

Digitalization Changes the Equation

One of Northern Europe’s less celebrated economic advantages is the sophistication of its digital public infrastructure. Denmark and Estonia offer particularly interesting examples, having invested heavily in digital identity, electronic public services, and the integration of government information systems. Rather than requiring businesses and citizens to navigate a succession of disconnected administrative offices, their systems increasingly allow transactions to be completed through shared digital infrastructure.

The OECD Digital Government Outlook 2026: Denmark provides some useful evidence. Denmark achieved a score of 0.83 out of 1.00 in the OECD’s 2025 Digital Government Index, comfortably above the OECD average of 0.70. Interestingly, Estonia achieved exactly the same overall score, although their respective strengths reveal differences in how the two countries approach digital public administration.

Table 3. Digital government, Denmark versus Estonia (OECD Digital Government Index 2025)

Digital government dimensionDenmarkEstoniaOECD average
Government as a Platform0.920.810.71
Digital by Design0.880.710.75
Data-driven Public Sector0.830.930.74
Proactiveness0.790.920.67
Open by Default0.810.870.59
User-Driven0.720.720.71
Overall score0.830.830.70

Note. Scores range from 0 (lowest) to 1 (highest). Bold marks the higher-scoring country in each row. The index assesses digital government capabilities, not the direct cost of business regulatory compliance.

Source. OECD, Digital Government Outlook 2026, Annex Table 1.A.1 (2025 Digital Government Index).

https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/digital-government-outlook-2026_d46c0555-en/denmark_09ccf596-en.html

https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/digital-government-outlook-2026_d46c0555-en/estonia_f5640fed-en.html

Their identical overall scores conceal different institutional strengths. Denmark excels in shared digital infrastructure, while Estonia stands out in data-driven administration and proactive public services. Neither approach is inherently superior, but both demonstrate how institutional design can simplify the collection, exchange, and processing of information.

Consider establishing a business in Denmark. Through Virk, the Danish Business Authority’s digital portal, entrepreneurs can register companies, obtain a CVR identification number, and access numerous administrative services. Digital identity and electronic communication facilitate subsequent interactions with public authorities, reducing the need to submit identical information through disconnected administrative channels. The practical benefit is not necessarily fewer legal obligations, but the possibility of satisfying them with less duplication, lower transaction costs, and greater predictability.

This distinction brings us back to Adam Smith’s concern with obstacles to productive activity. Digitalization does not automatically reduce regulation, but it can make compliance less burdensome, allowing businesses to devote more resources to productive purposes. Whether those efficiencies ultimately reduce the total administrative burden is another question.

The Danish Model Is Not Without Friction

None of this suggests that Denmark has eliminated bureaucracy. The OECD Economic Survey of Denmark 2026 identifies substantial administrative burdens, particularly for smaller businesses. According to the OECD, approximately four in ten Danish micro and small enterprises report that more than 10% of their staff work on compliance and reporting activities. This represents a considerable commitment of resources, particularly for companies with limited administrative capacity.

There is, however, a potential paradox at the heart of digital administration. In principle, technology can make individual reporting obligations easier to satisfy while also lowering the practical barriers to introducing additional requirements. A procedure that once demanded hours of paperwork might now take minutes, but if reporting obligations multiply, the aggregate administrative burden may remain unchanged or even increase. Could digitalization make bureaucracy more efficient without necessarily making government less bureaucratic? The possibility deserves closer examination, particularly through evidence of how reporting requirements and compliance costs evolve over time.

The distinction is consequential. A more efficient administrative process does not automatically justify the regulation behind it, just as the existence of a regulatory obligation does not necessarily make it economically undesirable. The challenge for policymakers is to distinguish between requirements that serve legitimate public interests and those that impose unnecessary costs. Technology should help achieve that objective, rather than simply make an expanding regulatory framework easier to administer.

A Good Place to Do Business

What, then, can we conclude from these findings? The FIU study highlights the administrative time associated with establishing and operating businesses, while the Bundesbank’s research provides additional evidence of the costs German companies attribute to bureaucracy. The IMD rankings offer a broader perspective, demonstrating that competitiveness encompasses more than administrative efficiency. Denmark’s institutional strengths and digital capabilities suggest that the quality of public administration deserves as much attention as the extent of regulation itself. Nevertheless, digital sophistication is no panacea. The challenge is not merely to make administrative procedures faster, but to ensure that regulatory obligations remain proportionate to their intended purpose.

For entrepreneurs and investors, Denmark presents a compelling combination of institutional stability, sophisticated digital infrastructure, a highly skilled workforce, and a competitive business environment. High taxation, expensive labor, and substantial administrative obligations remain important considerations, particularly for smaller enterprises. Nevertheless, the predictability of its institutions and the efficiency of its public services offer advantages that are easily overlooked when economic freedom is judged primarily by the extent of government intervention.

Adam Smith recognized that individual enterprise depends on an institutional framework that protects economic activity without unnecessarily obstructing it. Two hundred and fifty years after The Wealth of Nations, that principle remains relevant, particularly as digitalization creates new opportunities to simplify administration without necessarily reducing regulation. Denmark offers no definitive answer to the relationship between bureaucracy and competitiveness, but it demonstrates why the quality of public administration deserves closer examination. For anyone considering where to establish a business in Europe, little Denmark deserves a serious look.


Subscribe

Get new essays by email as soon as they are published.

Keep reading

Featured image for “When the Reserve Asset Changes, the Bond Markets Notice First”

When the Reserve Asset Changes, the Bond Markets Notice First

Brett S. ChappellInvestment,LearningsBond Markets,Central Banking,Exchange Rates,Fixed Income,Global Markets,Institutional Credibility,Market Structure,Monetary Policy,Sovereign Debt,Term Premium,U.S. Treasuries,Yield Curve

Bretton Woods anchored money to convertibility. The post-1971 system anchored it to credibility. Today, exchange rates and balance sheet policy are increasingly part of the same surface, and the bond market is where those pressures first become visible. The long end is no longer just pricing inflation. It is pricing institutional discipline.