Stewardship6 min read

When the Voice on the Phone Is Not the Person You Know

ByBrett S. Chappell

There is a comfortable assumption behind many fraud stories: the victim must have missed something obvious. A spelling mistake, a strange email address, an implausible request, or some other warning sign that a more experienced or skeptical person would have caught.

The recent fraud involving Fideuram, the private-banking arm of Intesa Sanpaolo, challenges that assumption.

In February 2026, Paolo Molesini, then chairman of Fideuram, received a WhatsApp message from someone claiming to be Carlo Messina, CEO of parent company Intesa Sanpaolo. The supposed Messina said an urgent and highly confidential overseas acquisition needed to be executed through Fideuram.

This was not a mass-market phishing email. It was a carefully constructed social-engineering exercise built around authority, familiarity, confidentiality, and a transaction that was plausible enough to withstand initial scrutiny.

How the fraud worked

The WhatsApp message came from a number different from the one Molesini knew, but the story did not depend on that message alone. He was told that a lawyer from a prominent international firm would contact him regarding the transaction.

That call subsequently arrived. The caller appeared to be Paolo Nastasi, managing partner of A&O Shearman in Italy, whom Molesini knew. Nastasi was entirely uninvolved. According to the Milan investigation reported by ANSA, the criminals had used artificial intelligence to reproduce his voice.

The apparent lawyer then supplied eleven documents, including a confidentiality agreement and what appeared to be a special power of attorney signed by Messina. Banking details for the transfers followed. At the same time, according to the judicial material reported by ANSA, Fideuram’s head of treasury and payments was separately contacted by somebody impersonating another senior Fideuram executive and told to expect urgent and confidential payment instructions from Molesini.

The fraudsters had therefore created something more convincing than a fake message. They had constructed a surrounding reality in which several apparently independent signals pointed in the same direction.

The regulatory angle matters

One part of the story is particularly revealing.

According to ANSA’s account of the investigation, Molesini was told that Intesa could not make the acquisition directly because a leak could lead to intervention by Consob, the Italian securities regulator. The transaction therefore supposedly needed to be conducted through Fideuram. ANSA reports that Molesini did not find the explanation suspicious because an earlier acquisition had already fallen away following a leak.

Psychologically, that is an important detail. The criminals were not merely asking their victim to keep quiet. They appear to have turned secrecy into part of the compliance narrative. Asking too many questions or widening the circle could itself seem capable of creating the very regulatory problem that everyone was supposedly trying to avoid.

For an experienced executive, that changes the nature of the pressure. Urgency, confidentiality, and regulatory sensitivity are all perfectly normal features of genuine transactions. In this case, they became tools for suppressing the normal instinct to verify.

The result was a series of transfers totaling close to €95 million, mainly toward accounts in China and Hong Kong. Fideuram detected irregularities quickly enough to recover or block most of the money. Reuters reported approximately €53 million recovered, while later ANSA reporting based on judicial documents put the amount still missing at €39.5 million.

Smart people get defrauded too

The victim here was not an inexperienced private client responding to an unexpected email. He was chairman of a major private bank within one of Europe’s largest banking groups.

That should matter to anyone who thinks sophistication provides immunity from fraud.

Social engineering works precisely because human beings use context to make decisions. We trust people we know. We recognize voices. We understand how our organizations work. We know that certain transactions really are confidential, certain instructions really are urgent, and senior executives sometimes communicate outside formal channels.

Artificial intelligence gives criminals better tools for exploiting those judgments.

The important point is not that AI somehow penetrated Fideuram’s payment systems. According to the reporting, the bank’s IT systems were not breached. Human beings authorized the transfers because the surrounding story appeared credible.

A particular problem for private wealth

That should concern family offices and private-banking clients because substantial private wealth is often managed within relatively small circles of trust.

A family principal may have worked with the same private banker, lawyer, accountant, or investment adviser for twenty years. People know one another’s voices and habits. Transactions can involve large sums, family members may be traveling, legitimate deals may require discretion, and WhatsApp or similar services often sit alongside more formal communications.

Those relationships make private wealth management efficient. They also give a sophisticated fraudster something to imitate.

The answer is not to abandon trusted relationships. It is to separate trust in the person from verification of the instruction.

For an unusual or material transfer:

  • Do not verify it using the telephone number, email address, or link contained in the request itself.
  • Call the person back using contact details already held independently.
  • Require additional authorization when the beneficiary is new, the destination unusual, or the amount exceptional.
  • Treat urgency, secrecy, and supposed regulatory sensitivity as reasons for stronger checks, not reasons to bypass them.
  • Agree within the family or family office, before anything happens, how exceptional payment instructions will be authenticated.

These are remarkably low-tech defenses against an increasingly high-tech problem.

The value of familiarity has changed

For years, the sensible response to a suspicious financial instruction was to pick up the telephone and confirm it. That remains good advice, but Fideuram shows why it now needs qualification. A familiar voice calling you is no longer necessarily independent verification when that voice itself can be manufactured.

The broader lesson is that some of the signals we have traditionally used to establish authenticity are losing their evidentiary value. A recognizable voice, an authoritative document, detailed knowledge of an organization, or a plausible explanation from somebody who appears to know the transaction can all now be reproduced more convincingly than before.

For families and advisers responsible for significant wealth, the practical response is neither fear nor technological escalation. It is disciplined procedure. Trust can remain personal, but verification has to become independent.

The old advice still works. Pick up the phone, but use your own number.


References

Reuters, September 25, 2026 https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/ai-messaging-scam-costs-italys-top-bank-intesa-millions-sources-say-2026-09-25/

ANSA, September 25, 2026 https://www.ansa.it//sito/notizie/cronaca/2026/09/25/truffa-da-395-milioni-allex-capo-di-fideuram-un-indagato_f747847d-aaa5-4f5f-9bee-1d476b6bea1e.html


Corriere della Sera, September 25, 2026 https://milano.corriere.it/notizie/cronaca/26_settembre_25/fideuram-truffa-falso-messaggio-whatsapp-molesini-milioni-d5248b46-a7e7-4130-8c74-e09be5e00xlk.shtml

Subscribe

Get new essays by email as soon as they are published.

Keep reading

Featured image for “Why Most Family Offices Should Fail (And How to Build the Rare Exception)”

Why Most Family Offices Should Fail (And How to Build the Rare Exception)

Marc O. DinesFamily Offices,Investment,Learnings,SustainabilityLife Perspectives,Stewardship

Why Most Family Offices Should Fail (And How to Build the Rare Exception) “Adversity is sometimes hard upon a man, but for one man who can stand prosperity, there are a hundred that will stand adversity“ Thomas Carlyle, Scottish historian and philosopher (1795-1881) Unfinished portrait of Thomas Carlyle by John Everett Millais (1877). Source: National […]